By Suzanne Fenske, MD, FACOG, ABOIM, MSCP
Fasting for Women
Fasting holds promises of weight loss and health, but is it right for women? And more importantly, is it right for you?
Truthfully, fasting is a complex and individual matter. Some people may see significant benefit, while others may experience downsides and hormone disruption. It also depends on the type of fasting and how much. Is it done in a health-promoting way, or is it just a guise for restriction and disordered eating behaviors?
Fasting is just a tool, but how you use it determines if it’s helpful or backfires. Today’s article will explore fasting for women, with a focus on intermittent fasting. Keep reading as we discuss:
What is Fasting? What is Intermittent Fasting?
Fasting is a broad term that refers to abstaining from food and drink, except water. There are some forms of fasting, such as the fasting-mimicking diet, where calorie intake is significantly restricted, but you still eat some food.
When you think of fasting, you may think of water fasting or juice cleanses, which are often marketed as quick weight loss and detox strategies. Alternatively, you may be aware of intermittent fasting, which has been a dominant nutrition trend over the last decade. While there are many types of fasting, we’ll focus on intermittent fasting in this article.
Intermittent fasting, also known as time-restricted eating, is a structured fasting strategy where one alternates periods of regular eating with fasting. Intermittent fasting involves short fasts, typically lasting 24 hours or less, practiced regularly with the goal of improving health. The time restriction creates a calorie restriction, eliminating the need to count or track food intake.
There are several types of intermittent fasting:
What is the Purpose of Fasting?
People may fast for spiritual reasons or as a strategy to detoxify, rest the digestive system, or lose weight. But the benefits may go deeper.
Numerous animal and human studies on intermittent fasting have demonstrated health benefits. However, most human studies use men as subjects, and there is a need for more studies, especially longer trials, focusing on women.
Nonetheless, some interesting things happen in the body when it’s in a fasted state. As fasting progresses, the body is no longer receiving new glucose, so it’s forced to release glycogen (stored glucose) from the liver and muscles. When this fuel source depletes, the body shifts to burning fat (as ketones) instead of glucose.
As fasting continues, autophagy begins. Autophagy is the housekeeping mechanism within cells; which eliminates waste and recycles molecules to enhance cellular health and function. Autophagy is associated with longevity.
A primary benefit of intermittent fasting is weight loss. Unlike other forms of dieting that promote weight loss, intermittent fasting allows for weight (fat) loss while preserving muscle. We don’t have long-term studies, but this appears to be the case in the short- to medium-term.
Other benefits may include:
Women’s Health – Menopause and PCOS
Intermittent fasting benefits both premenopausal and postmenopausal women when it’s used as a therapeutic tool. However, there is no one-size-fits-all approach, and we consider many factors for each individual.
In a recently published pilot study of postmenopausal women over 8 weeks, participants followed either an intermittent fasting diet (adhering to the 16:8 method, eating only between 7 am and 3 pm) or a low-calorie diet (providing 75% of daily needs). Both groups also participated in a HIIT (high-intensity interval training) exercise program. Researchers concluded that those following the fasting and HIIT program achieved better body composition and physical performance (including heart rate and VO2 max).
For women in perimenopause and menopause, it’s possible that well-placed fasting can help offset the metabolic changes that occur because of declining reproductive hormones.
PCOS (polycystic ovarian syndrome) is another area where fasting may be beneficial. A review of human and animal studies suggests that intermittent fasting reduces androgen levels and improves menstrual regulation in PCOS.
In a small study of women with PCOS and anovulation (no ovulation), the participants followed a 16:8 intermittent fasting schedule for 5 weeks. After the 5 weeks, 73% of participants saw an improvement in menstrual cycle regularity. Additional benefits were weight loss, body fat reduction, improved insulin sensitivity, reduced inflammation, and lower androgen levels.
Who Shouldn’t Fast
Postmenopausal women and women with PCOS are two populations where intermittent fasting may be beneficial. However, it’s important to note that when it comes to fasting, more isn’t always better. Excessive fasting can disrupt the menstrual cycle and ovulation, negatively impact hormones, and compound other stressors in one’s life.
We don’t recommend fasting for women:
Intermittent Fasting Tips for Women
The more extreme versions of intermittent fasting may be challenging to sustain over time and, in many ways, can become another crash diet. Instead, we encourage thinking of fasting as a tool in your toolkit and using it gently as you focus on building long-term health habits.
Using intermittent fasting as a way to end late-night snacking is likely beneficial, but pushing your body too far (when you already have a lot on your plate) can exacerbate symptoms and worsen hormone imbalances.
Here are some ideas for getting started with fasting, safely and gently:
Many fasting approaches are very restrictive and challenging to implement within a busy and active lifestyle. However, some gentle intermittent fasting when it’s a good fit, may help unlock metabolic advantages and promote healing. You don’t have to figure it out on your own; TārāMD can help.
References